FRANCE / POLITICAL PERSPECTIVE

ENGLISH

Ochlarchy andanarchism

Strategic Chaos and the “Strongman”

In France today, it is only the fascists of the National Rally—with Le Pen at the helm—who benefit from ochlarchy, including the chaos that accompanies it. Ochlarchy is broadly defined as “mob rule,” encompassing chaos and similar phenomena.

Friske Fraspark · Source: AIIS ·

Read the analysis ↓

Ochlarchy and political activism

This perspective highlights a deep and fundamental divide in how political activism, violence, and anarchism are understood. The argument that “Black Bloc” tactics and masked rioting effectively function as a fascist strategy to incite chaos touches upon several key historical and political-science mechanisms.

Below is an overview of how this dynamic and its historical parallels are analyzed:

Strategic Chaos and the “Strongman”

The core of the argument is supported by classical political-science theory regarding the emergence of authoritarian regimes and dictatorships. This mechanism often unfolds as follows:

  1. Provoking instability

    Masked groups or provocateurs incite vandalism, violence, and volatile, chaotic situations in the streets (ochlarchy/mob rule).

  2. Discrediting anarchism

    By having the media and the public mistakenly label this chaos as “anarchy,” the genuine anarchist ideal—which envisions a peaceful, free, and highly organized horizontal social structure—becomes associated with pure destruction.

  3. Demands for order

    When the population feels unsafe due to persistent rioting and lawlessness, it creates fertile ground for a counter-reaction. People begin to demand law and order at any cost.

  4. Totalitarian takeover

    This opens the door for authoritarian leaders (“the strongman”) who promise to restore law and order through an iron fist, increased state surveillance, a militarized police force, and the curtailment of freedoms. In this way, street chaos—ironically—serves the interests of the totalitarian state.

The Comparison: Blackshirts vs. Black Bloc

Although the modern “Black Bloc” and the historical “Blackshirts” (Squadristi) have somewhat different stated ideologies, there are clear parallels in how they manifest in the streets:

  • Uniformity and anonymity

    Both groups employ a standardized dress code to signal collective strength, deter opponents, and make it difficult for authorities to identify individuals.
  • Extra-legal use of force

    The use of physical violence, vandalism, and confrontation outside of established democratic or legal channels to achieve political objectives.
  • Risk of infiltration

    Because anyone can put on black clothing and a mask, this method is highly vulnerable to infiltration—by intelligence services (using agents provocateurs), fascists, or other extremists who may wish to escalate the situation for their own ends.

The Implications for the Libertarian Movement

From a consistent and principled anarchist perspective, there is a clear distinction between destructive mob rule (ochlarchy) and anarchism:

  1. Anarchism requires order: Anarchism means “without rulers,” not “without law and order.”
  2. The goal is reflected in the means: If the goal is a free, horizontal, and non-violent society, the means cannot consist of authoritarian violence, terror, or indiscriminate destruction.

The fact that international anarchist organizations (such as the IAT-APT) resort to the exclusion—issuing “brown cards”—of such factions underscores precisely the need to protect the original movement from being hijacked by forces that—consciously or unconsciously—pave the way for totalitarian rule.

A totalitarian takeover

In France today, it is only the fascists of the National Rally, led by Le Pen, who benefit from this state of ochlarchy (mob rule) and the accompanying chaos. A totalitarian takeover: this opens the door for authoritarian leaders—the “strongman” figure—who promise to restore law and order through an iron fist, increased state surveillance, a militarized police force, and the curtailment of civil liberties. In this way, street chaos ironically serves the interests of the totalitarian state.

Regards Friske Fraspark. Source: AIIS .